Home Anal Toys The Best 10 Tailed Butt Plugs: Yea! This Can Be Your Fairy Tail!

The Best 10 Tailed Butt Plugs: Yea! This Can Be Your Fairy Tail!

by Jane Louis

Tailed butt plugs are one of the sexiest accessories you can use for role play, especially for those of you who are into anal play.

Some people may feel a bit uncomfortable, even a bit shamed trying tailed butt plugs (or butt plugs in general).

This is totally common! That’s why I am creating a safe place for you to open up to the knowledge of your sexuality and be free to explore the pleasure in your rear.

With the necessary information about tailed butt plugs, you will be able to make a completely safe and sensational choice.


fox tail anal plug

1. Dominix Stainless-Steel Fox Tail 


b-vibe rainbow tail set

2. B-Vibe Vibrating Rainbow Pony Tail


fox tail butt plug with ear

3. Tailz Wolf Anal Plug & Matching Ears

tailed butt plug play couple

The charm of tailed butt plugs is that you can use it not only in the bedroom during sex, but also in every day fantasy play, such as while doing chores around the house or running errands.

Some people like to use the tailed anal plug just for a few minutes during foreplay.

But others prefer to have it attached for hours, just to enjoy the fulfillment from the anal part. You can do whatever that is to your like.

Top 10 Tailed Butt Plugs You Should Not Miss

1. Inviting Dominix Deluxe Stainless-Steel Fox Tail Butt Plug

lovehoney fox tail butt plug

Foxtails are one of my favorites when it comes to animal play. The Dominix fox tail plug is made of stainless steel and faux fur and it provides unforgettable sensation when inserted.

The tails itself is soft to hold in the hand and it can provide some soft tickle on the butt gap and between the thighs.

The toy is around 14.5 inches in total length and there is a range of size options for the butt plug, from 2.5 inches to 4-inch insertable length.

I personally picked the Medium one and it was a good size for me.

The metal plug is heavier than glass or silicone plugs, but it is very comfortable and actually more pleasant due to the weight!

And the weight of it feels extremely amazing when you move.

Besides, the metal surface makes it perfect for temperature play, cold or warm; and it encourages easy insertion during the play.

Also, for those of you who are concerned about hygiene, it’s possible to clean because you can easily unscrew the foxtail from the plug!


  • Great for temperature playThe softness of the fur
  • Amazing sensation thanks to the weight
  • Removable tail
  • Cutest of the look


  • Takes time to clean the fur, esp. when the lube is on it
  • The tail is not that long

I know different people have different fantasies, some are especially into white or red foxtail, others are craving for long fox tail butt plug.

If you are looking for fox set that comes with both tail and matching ears to play with, I would recommend the this Taliz kit (picture below).


2. B-Vibe Unicore Vibrating Anal Toy with Tail

B-Vibe Unicore Vibrating Anal Toy with Tail

Here comes my new favorite - b-vibe unicore vibrating anal plug with a rainbow tail! 

When it comes to anal toys, B-Vibe is my go-to brand and I was so exciting finding out they launched a ponytail butt plug. 

As expected, the vibration is strong and rumbly!

With the 6 vibration patterns and 10 levels of intensity, I was able to explore a wide range of sensations, from gentle tickling to crazily intense. 

The plug is made of high-quality silky smooth silicone in its entirety. It has an insertable size of 4.4 in/11.2 cm, which is perfect for everyday players. 

Besides, the tapered tip makes sure of an easy and comfortable insertion while the spiral textured design sends some extra thrills while inserted.  

The removable tail is 19 in/48 cm in length and it's made of multicolor synthetic fiber. And it can be attached to the butt plug simply through a magnetic pin.

Also, the fact the tail is detachable makes it a lot easier to clean. 

Here are 6 pieces included in this value set:

This is a limited edition toy, but I really hope they won't stop selling it because I believe everyone who's into animal fantasy play should try it. This is the best tailed toy I've had!


  • Strong vibration and 10 levels of intensity
  • Great for intermediate anal play
  • Textured design for tugging and twisting
  • Tail is detachable & washable
  • Tapered head for easy insertion
  • Gender neutral


  • Magnetic clip may get loose while in play
  • Not 100% waterproof (it's splashproof)

3. Cute Pom Pom Butt Plugs by Blush Novelties

buddy tail butt plug

This adorable and sexy pompom is an irresistible toy to add to your anal plug collection.

It’s a perfect rabbit bunny butt plug that can transfer you in a naughty form.

No matter what kind of rabbit bunny play you want to be in, this classic shape and soft silicone will fill you up and stay firmly in place.

Shake your butt and ask for a nice hard carrot!

This bunny butt plug is light, tapered, and petite so that insertion is easy and enjoyable, even for beginners.

It adds new sensations to either solo or partnered pet play. You can even go take a walk with this cute little tail

Besides, the premium material is non-porous and cleans easily as the sleeve is removable.

  • Length: 5.00 Inches
  • Width: 1.40 Inches
  • Weight: 2.6 Ounces


  • Easily to insert
  • Soft and quality faux fur
  • Great for animal play
  • Easy to clean


  • Nothing

4. Alluring Dominix Deluxe Glass Faux Fur Cat Tail Butt Plug

cat tail lovehoney

Who doesn’t want to be a cat? Cat is such a creature that is naturally mysterious and sexy and they know what they want… I mean what they want at the butt!

With a glass butt plug at one end and fluffy faux fur tail at the other, this Dominix Deluxe toy is Purrrfect for those of you who want to have cat role-play while enhancing anal pleasure.

The tapered anal plug is shaped in easy insertion and the glass texture makes sure it’s smooth to slide in.

Thanks to the flared base, you won’t need to worry about over-insertion.

The cattail extends from its base, spicing up your bedroom sex with some wildness. Well, it’s time to show your “cattitude”!


  • Affordable
  • Comfortable insertion
  • Soft fur
  • Fur doesn't fall out easily
  • Sensitive-skin friendly


  • Can’t remove the tail for washing

5. Foxxy Fanny Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug

vibrating tailed butt plug

What’s better than a tail butt plug? A vibrating tail butt plug!

This white and fluffy fox tail actually fulfills 2 of my fantasies – wearing a real tail and let it vibrates!

What can I say, the vibration can bring out your animal part very easily.

The tail is super soft to touch, the plug is easy to insert (with a little bit of lube) and is comfortable when inserted.

The soft, smooth plug as a looped bullet holder, and comes with a strong battery-operated butt vibe for sizzling sensation. 

The Foxxy butt plug is made of premium silicone, which is non-porous and cleans easily. 

  • Total length: 19 inches
  • Insertable length: 4 inches (1.4 inches in diameter)
  • Weight: 0.46 lbs


  • It vibrates
  • Very soft tail
  • Comfortable to insert and stay in
  • Ideal for pet play


  • Vibration can be stronger
  • The vibe is not rechargeable

6. Pretty Lovehoney Jeweled Butt Plug Selections

diamond butt plug

Ranging from 2.5 to 4 inches (6 -10 cm), Lovehoney offers a selection of butt plugs that looks as good as it feels.

They all are beautifully bulbous and are embellished with a sparkly jewel in different colors and shapes. 

There is a wide range of colors, shapes, and sizes to choose from. Fancy a pink jeweled butt plug or a heart jeweled butt plug? You get them all!

Some of the butt plug’s insertable part is made of silicone, others are made of natural materials such as glass and stainless steel.

My personal favorite is the 3.5 Inch jeweled metal butt plug because it's girthy and has a satisfying weight of 331 grams for deliciously full sensations.

The stainless steel makes it great for temperature play exciting and experiencing warm or cool sensations. 

The base of the toy is big, which leaves no worry for any advanced anal play.

Besides, the smooth surface, along with the tapered tip also encourages also encourage easy insertion and is very smooth to insert.

Once inserted, you will understand why I say it feels fantastic inside!


  • Easy insertion (smooth + tapered point)
  • Firm and long lasting
  • Very Easy to Clean
  • Removable tail
  • Cutest of the look


  • A bit heavy

Update 2021: If you are looking for a powerful vibrating jewel plug, make sure to check the new launch from b-vibe.

7. Tailz Puppy Play Set: Perfect for Puppy Play

Tailz Puppy Play

This little puppy butt plug is here to combine your fantasy of puppy play with some butt-centric stimulation.

A dog is our loyal pal and this one is no exception! This silicone puppy tail is dedicated to bringing you some ultimately sensational play.

Anyone who wears this puppy tail butt plug is bound to end up wagging it in delight while making some deep connections with their owner

The tail part is really unique, it has this bouncy texture which means any touch of the tail can transfer some shivering movement inside of the hole.

It’s a toy made of medical-grade silicone, totally waterproof and very easy to clean

With a little bit of lube, it will slide in your rear and transfer you into a cute puppy or a wild b*tch. It’s up to you to choose.

Ready to fulfill some animal play fetish and take some puppy training?

  • Total Length: 12.1in/30.7cm
  • Insertable Length: 3.6in/9.1cm
  • Tail Length: 8.5in/21.6cm
  • Max Diameter: 1.2in/3cm


  • Unique design
  • Comfortable to insert
  • Medical-grade silicone in its entirety
  • Large and girthy
  • Waterproof
  • Easy to clean
  • Easy to store


  • Can be a bit too long for some people

8. Tailz Black Silicone Anal Plug with Wolf Tail & Matching Ears (Grey)

grey foxtail butt plug

If you are someone who likes matching things and go wolfie, this is perfect for you!

I paid less than $40 for this wolf set and was thrilled by its high-quality. It’s amazingly sexy to do some wolf play with my partner.

Once having the anal plug inserted, I can feel the wildness going out! Try having some riding sex with this toy inserted, you two will both be howling in pleasure.

The plug itself is pretty nice on its own, classically shaped, and well-sized for a nice distinct stretch. 

The best part though is definitely an extra-long, ultra-fluffy grey wolf tail that flows down from the base. 

Despite being faux fur, it feels really realistic, which again confirms its high-quality!

The adorable headband with matching ears will complete your ensemble. Stalk your prey or crawl around like a sexy wolf!

  • Weight (Product): 155 g (5.47 oz)
  • Length (Anal Plug & Tail): 597 mm (23.5")
  • Length (Tail): 483 mm (19")
  • Length (Plug): 114 mm (4.5")
  • Insertable Length (Plug): 102 mm (4")
  • Max Diameter (Plug): 44 mm (1.75")


  • Soft fur
  • Good quality
  • Good price
  • Ears included


  • Need a great amount of lube to help insertion

9. Crystal Delights My Lil Rainbow Pony Tail

ponytail rainbow butt plug

Isn’t owning a Rainbow butt plug tail THE DREAM? This Ponytail by Crystal Delights is a delightful toy to add to your pet play scenario.

It’s an absolute high-quality tail butt plug, which is made of properly hardened borosilicate glass and is excellent for hot or cold temperature play.

Sliding in the plug is simpler than I thought. The glass surface makes it comfortable to wear, even for a long time.

This is a princess-look toy, but it can definitely bring out your wild side!

  • Insertable Length: 2.8 inches
  • Depth: 3.4 inches
  • Height: 15 inches
  • Width: 1.3 inches

Other than the rainbow color, it's also possible to get it in lavender, pink and blue colors. 


  • Dreamy color
  • Great for temperature play
  • Very high-quality tail
  • Cutest of the look
  • Handcrafted glass anal plug
  • Easy to insert
  • Easy to clean (tail is detachable)


  • Pricy

Why Include Tailed Butt Plugs in Your Sex Play?

Despite that anal sex is not something that everyone will enjoy, research shows that 43% of men (insertive) and 37% of women (receptive) have experienced backdoor sex.

Why do people enjoy anal stimulation? For men, the stimulation of the prostate gland can bring intense pleasure and according to LELO, prostate orgasms are 33 percent bigger than penile orgasms.

For women, the anus and vagina share a mutual wall and that’s why the G-spot can often be stimulated while the anus is stimulated.

tailed butt plug in sex

Tailed butt plugs not only can give desired stimulation inside of your anus, but it also creates a pleasant visual effect that levels up to normal sex to an erotic animal role play.

Some tailed butt plugs even include vibrating functions, which ensures a higher level of pleasure.

These people whose wearing it will be intensively stimulated and they can’t stop moving the butt and moan – What a scene!

That’s why tailed butt plug is a sex toy that contains both sensational and visional charms and

the results of using it will be very satisfying for you and your partner.

How to Use a Tailed Butt Plug?

Plugs are made from a variety of materials including soft materials such as silicone as well as firm materials such as glass or metal.

If you tailed butt plug is made of natural materials such as glass and stainless steel, you will also be able to do some temperature play.

Either warm them up or cool them down before insertion can bring you some special sensation that others toys won’t able to mimic.

sexy foxtail butt plug

Tailed butt plugs come in all types of sizes as well. Beginner's plugs are usually less wide at their thickest point while more advanced anal plugs may be wider.

Some plugs are freestanding toys, while others may include vibrators for stimulation.

You will be able to find tailed butt plugs that can transfer you into any animal forms, the sexiest will be ponytail and foxtail in my opinion.

To start playing with your tailed anal plug, you will need to very well lubricate the area.

Not like the vagina, the anus lacks natural lubrication so it can easily be torn if not being careful.

Besides, make sure your tailed butt plug has a flared base so that it will get stuck inside. Your anus is a sucking machine. 

If without a handle or base to easily pull out the toy, you may end up in the hospital, explaining the awkward situations.

Hygiene should always be the order of the day. So, you should wash the anus area before any interaction.

This is to be respectful of yourself and your partner. And of course, it is also highly recommended to clean the anal plug well before each use!

anal sex vibe

App-controllable vibrating butt plugs

One last thing I would like to mention is … umm... it’s not pretty, but very likely you will see some sh*t.

No matter how well you try to clean your rear area, it’s impossible to remove all the “things” inside unless you are willing to practice enema.

(I am not going to talk about enema in details, but the thing you need to know is that it’s not recommended to use enema too often and it takes time to learn how to do it.)

Therefore, you should be mentally prepared to see some brown things if you are willing to explore some anal pleasure.

My Experience Using Tailed Butt Plugs

To be honest, I am not super into anal play, but I am very triggered by animal role play.

Wearing a costume is one thing, but wearing a tail is just so much sexier in my mind.

That’s how I opened myself to tailed butt plugs. I slowly introduced myself to this field and I spent plenty of time gathering the necessary information before actually feeling safe to try it.

I tested a ponytail butt plug myself before using it with my partner.

I took a toy that is 4.25 in circumference and 3 inches in length.

It was a bit too big for me and the insertion took quite some time.

anal sex toys play

After applying a very generous amount of lube, my muscle finally got dilated and it went in.

The stimulation from the rear area is very different from the vaginal part. I felt filled and wrapped.

To increase the sensation, I took out a G-spot vibrator to take care of the other hole and that worked like a wonder.

Because of the fulfillment from the anus, my G-spot got more sensitive and I was able to feel the pleasure more intensely.

g spot vibe

I told my partner about this experience and he’s very interested in trying it with me. He also mentioned doing some public play.

I am not going out with my ponytail because that will be too obvious, but I am triggered to try the bunny tail. That will be fun for sure!

I will probably try having the bunny tail in the back and inserting an app-controllable egg vibrator such as Lovense Lush in the vagina.

I will share more with you once we put these ideas into action ;).

Until then, 

Take care! 

signature Jane L

You may also like

Leave a Comment